Survey: Dwelling Affordability Packing containers Out People Who Dream of Relocating

At NerdWallet, we try that can assist you make monetary choices with confidence. To do that, many or all the merchandise featured listed below are from our companions. Nonetheless, this doesn’t affect our evaluations. Our opinions are our personal.

It’s one factor to dream about residing in utterly new environment; it’s one other (generally pricey endeavor) to pack up and transfer.

About one-fourth (26%) of People would favor to reside in a special location sort — be it a metropolis, suburb, small city or rural space — and lots of cite monetary causes as major obstacles to getting there, based on a NerdWallet survey of over 2,000 U.S. adults carried out on-line from July 30 to Aug. 1, 2019, by The Harris Ballot.

“In terms of the place we reside, some are cursed with extra choices than alternatives — it’s not so simple as packing up and going,” says NerdWallet mortgages skilled Holden Lewis. “We lengthy to go away our sleepy suburbs for the thrilling metropolis, or we dream of ditching town for a quiet small city. However shifting is pricey — you could have your job and a brand new value of residing to consider, and also you’re typically leaving family and friends behind.”

Word: All through this report, references to residing location, environment or space confer with the 4 location varieties within the survey — metropolis or metro space, suburb, small city and rural space.

To uncover People’ sentiments, the survey didn’t outline location varieties and as an alternative requested respondents the place they lived versus the place they wish to reside based mostly on what they suppose is a metropolis, suburb, small city or rural space.

Key findings

One-fourth are eyeing greener grass. About one-quarter (26%) of People are usually not residing of their ultimate location sort, our survey discovered.
Affordability is the largest blocker. Of these People not residing of their ultimate location, 45% say it’s as a result of they will’t afford the properties they like in that place.
Metro space properties are exterior the vary of affordability. In near half of the nation’s 25 most populous metro areas, properties are promoting for at the least 5 occasions the median revenue for that location, based on NerdWallet’s evaluation.
Most People would make sacrifices to maneuver. Practically 7 in 10 (69%) of these not residing of their ultimate location would take motion to make a transfer occur. Amongst them, some are keen to start out working or tackle a second job (38%) or hand over all leisure journey (28%), the survey discovered.
Renters would forgo homeownership to maneuver. About 6 in 10 (61%) renters not residing of their ultimate location would somewhat hand over the chance to personal a house the place they at the moment reside if they may hire within the space they like.

» MORE: How does the price of residing evaluate in your ultimate location?

Not residing the place they wish to

Some folks reside the place they had been born and raised. Others might have relocated for school, a job, a relationship or private desire. Our survey discovered that People are most definitely to report residing in suburbs.


For extra survey information, together with why folks select these places, contact Thomas McLean at

However the place you at the moment reside isn’t essentially the place you wish to reside. Over one-fourth (26%) of People say they aren’t residing of their ultimate location sort. Small-town People are most definitely to be unhappy with their location — 44% of individuals in small cities don’t wish to reside there, in contrast with 30% of rural residents, 23% residing in cities and 21% of suburbanites. 

Of the generations surveyed about their present places, millennials (ages 23-38) residing in small cities or rural settings are most definitely to be unhappy — about half (49%) say they’re not residing of their ultimate location, in contrast with 30% of Gen X (ages 39-54) and 26% of child boomers (ages 55-73) who reside in these areas.

Affordability is a high barrier to shifting

Transferring is pricey, and shifting to a completely new neighborhood, not to mention a brand new location sort, can change how a lot you’re spending on housing, commuting and even groceries.

When requested what’s holding them again, 45% of People not at the moment residing of their ultimate location say they will’t afford properties of their most well-liked space. As nicely, 1 in 5 (20%) say they’ve an excessive amount of debt to have the ability to afford the transfer and nonetheless have sufficient for hire or mortgage funds.

“The locations with probably the most jobs — cities — even have the costliest housing,” Lewis says. “However, incomes are larger, too. Nonetheless, even when you discover a higher-paying job to make the housing prices manageable, relocation prices are daunting.”

» MORE: This step might prevent hundreds in your subsequent home

Houses in cities are notably out of attain

Those that would somewhat reside in a metropolis as an alternative of their present location are most definitely to quote the affordability of properties they like as a blocker — 62% say they will’t afford properties they like in a metropolis (in contrast with 41% of those that would somewhat reside within the suburbs, 36% of small-town hopefuls and 45% of these with their sights on a rural location). [1]

Cities usually tend to have median dwelling costs nicely over 3 times median incomes compared with different sorts of locations to reside. Median dwelling costs within the U.S. have traditionally been two-and-a-half to 4 occasions median incomes, based on the Brookings Establishment, and it’s inside this vary (or when dwelling costs are roughly 3 times median incomes) that housing prices are thought-about inexpensive.

In 2019, near half of the largest 25 metros — which embody a foremost metropolis and a few outlying suburbs — have dwelling costs at the least 5 occasions the estimated median revenue, based on NerdWallet’s evaluation. Within the San Francisco metro space, with the best home-price-to-income ratio, properties are promoting for over 10 occasions the median revenue.


Most would make sacrifices to maneuver

Practically 7 in 10 (69%) of these not residing the place they would favor would take motion to maneuver to their ultimate location, the survey discovered.

“Transferring forces you to alter the best way you save and spend,” Lewis says. “That goes double when you’re shopping for a house within the new place. If relocating is a high precedence, you may need to promote a automobile, take a part-time job or minimize your spending. However these sacrifices could also be completely value it if you find yourself in your dream environment.”

Renters prioritize location over homeownership

One sacrifice renters could also be keen to make to maneuver to their ultimate location: homeownership.

If given the selection to stay the place they’re and change into owners or transfer to their ultimate location and proceed renting, 61% of renters not at the moment of their ultimate location would select to maneuver.

Owners, alternatively, aren’t keen to make the swap to renting. Greater than three-fourths (78%) of householders not residing of their ultimate location say they’d somewhat keep put and proceed proudly owning than transfer and change into a renter.

“When you’ve owned your house, it’s tough to provide that up,” Lewis says. “Homeownership remains to be a part of the American dream for a lot of, so promoting your house and turning into a renter can really feel like downward mobility — even when renting is the higher possibility. I like to recommend silencing that inner voice and doing what’s greatest for you.”



The survey of U.S. adults ages 18 and older was carried out on-line July 30-Aug. 1, 2019, by The Harris Ballot. Of the two,015 within the survey, 512 don’t at the moment reside within the location sort the place they wish to be presently of their life. This on-line survey isn’t based mostly on a likelihood pattern and due to this fact no estimate of theoretical sampling error will be calculated. For full survey methodology, together with weighting variables and subgroup pattern sizes, contact Thomas McLean at

All through the report, residing location and placement sort confer with the place a house is in, as characterised by every respondent — a metropolis/metro space, suburb, small city or rural space.

For metropolitan space affordability ratios, we analyzed 2017 median incomes from the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Neighborhood Survey one-year estimates adjusted to Q2 2019 utilizing the Employment Value Index of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and Q2 2019 single-family dwelling costs from the Nationwide Affiliation of Realtors for the 25 most populous metro areas, excluding Detroit because of an absence of accessible information.


[1] Warning, low base dimension (n=97) – information needs to be interpreted as qualitative and directional in nature.

Rate this post

Related posts

Leave a Comment